This is a continuation of the first article. Since that piece was published, a great deal more has come out about Jason Arday — further claims, institutional responses, quiet edits, and the methods used to shut down scrutiny. You can read the original article here:
What follows is the fuller record.
Jason Arday does not like it when people ask him difficult questions.
When a journalist emailed Professor Jason Arday about textual overlaps in his PhD and about specific claims in his public record, Arday instructed Carter-Ruck — one of the most expensive reputation firms in the country. Their letter suggested the inquiries “may be, whether consciously or unconsciously, racially motivated.” The story was not published.
A harassment complaint was then made to the Metropolitan Police. Officers investigated for four months. They never interviewed the journalist. When they finally contacted him it was to close the case and to tell him not to contact Arday again, because the questions had affected Arday’s mental health. (reported by The Times and confirmed in subsequent coverage)
When an emeritus professor emailed about similarities in a published paper, Arday reported him for harassment too. That complaint was passed to another force and declined. (Dave Harris, as reported by The Telegraph)
This is the method:
Question him → lawyers + police + racism allegation.
That is how scrutiny has been shut down.
Here are the cards that have been played:
Autism / disability
Academic errors caused by autism. Reliance on “mimicry.” Complex learning disabilities. Inadequate supervision. Could not afford a proofreader.
Mental health
Questions from a journalist affected his mental health. Police advised the journalist not to contact him again for that reason.
Racism
A “very well orchestrated and co-ordinated campaign” that is “racially motivated.” Carter-Ruck told a news organisation the inquiries might be racially motivated. In his defence to Liverpool John Moores he argued the panel should consider the political context of a “war on critical race theory” and “insidious and relentless strategies” to remove Black academics under the guise of academic integrity.
Ableism
The same campaign is aligned with ableism.
Harassment
Reporting a journalist and an academic to the police for asking questions.
Legal threat
Instructing Carter-Ruck. Their letter stopped a planned investigation from being published.
“Believe me”
“To be honest with you, I thought you’d just believe me. Why would I lie?”
No receipts needed
“Nobody lives their life having a receipt for every single thing they say or they’ve done.”
Minimisation
“We’re talking about academia here. I didn’t murder somebody.”
Lightning rod / DEI
He has become a “lightning rod” for criticism of diversity, equity and inclusion policy.
There is almost no card left unplayed.
He has not said the game is up. He has doubled down. The origin story was the foundation on which an entire public career was built: the Cambridge chair, the honorary doctorates, the board positions, the media platforms, the speaking fees, the memoir deal. Question any of it and the whole structure is at risk. So the questions themselves become the offence — racism, harassment, a threat to mental health — and are met with lawyers and the police.
That is the context in which the rest of the record has to be read.
What the Origin Story Delivered
Broadcast and media
Guest Editor of BBC Radio 4’s Today Programme
Regular appearances and commentary for BBC, ITV News, CNN, Good Morning America and CBS
Writing and features in The Guardian and Times Higher Education
TEDx talks and festival appearances
Institutional and advisory roles
Member of the ITV Cultural Advisory Council
Trustee of the British Sociological Association
Former Trustee of the Runnymede Trust (reported as 11 years)
Member of the NHS Race and Health Observatory Academic Reference Group
Member of the Centre for Labour and Social Studies (CLASS) National Advisory Panel
Patron of the Adult Literacy Trust and Get Further
Trustee of Autism Action
Fellow of the Royal Society of Arts
Honorary Fellow of the British Science Association
Special adviser to the Parliaments of England, Wales and Scotland on race and racism
Honours and rankings
Multiple honorary doctorates
Listed 4th on the Shaw Trust Disability Power 100 (2023)
Named among the most influential people of 2023 by The Independent and The Guardian
Genius Within Neurodiversity Achiever of the Year (2023)
Most Inspirational Person of the Year (MBCC Awards, 2023)
Commercial
Simon & Schuster memoir deal (Great and Unfortunate Things)
Simon & Schuster Speakers Bureau representation
Paid speaking circuit built around the origin story
All of it built on the same unverified narrative. The Cambridge chair was the centrepiece. Everything else followed once the legend was accepted.
Honorary doctorates
He holds five. All were awarded after the Cambridge appointment. In every case the public citations rested on the same material: the origin story, the charity claims, and the “youngest Black professor” framing.
Anglia Ruskin University – Honorary Doctor of Education (2023). Citation focused on his academic journey from non-verbal child to Cambridge professor, his research, and his philanthropy.
Southampton Solent University – Honorary Doctor of Arts (July 2023). Cited as social commentator, academic, and fundraiser. The original citation included the extreme running claims; those were later removed.
St Mary’s University, Twickenham – Honorary Doctorate (July 2024). Awarded to an alumnus “in recognition of his contribution to academic life, his charity work, and the support he has given St Mary’s throughout his career.” Ceremony held in Westminster Cathedral.
University of Westminster – Honorary Doctor of Letters (July 2024). Cited as a scholar of race, inequality and education, and as the youngest person of colour ever appointed to a Cambridge professorship. The origin story featured heavily.
South Bank Colleges / London South Bank University – Honorary Doctorate (2024). Citation emphasised overcoming autism, his South London background, and his contribution to education and social change.
Two of the universities later walked parts of the record back. Anglia Ruskin changed “600 miles in six days” to “600 miles in twelve days.” Southampton Solent stripped the extreme running claims from its online citation entirely.
Cambridge Knew in 2023
On 19 May 2023 Martyn Hammersley emailed Hilary Cremin, Head of the Faculty of Education, and Rhys Morgan, Head of Policy. He flagged substantial plagiarism in Arday’s 2018 paper, including quotes attributed to Arday’s own interview subjects that matched quotes from another researcher’s participants. (emails first reported by Nathan Cofnas and later confirmed in The Telegraph)
On 21 June 2023 Morgan replied that it was “not within our remit.” Cremin said Arday had the department’s full support.
That is three years of Cambridge knowing. Everything that followed sits on top of that decision.
In the BBC’s 2023 video marking his appointment, Cremin went further. She said: “We are so lucky to have you. You are the best in the world in terms of the research that you do.” (BBC video, 2023)
Eight months later, on 2 February 2024, Arday was appointed to ITV’s Cultural Advisory Council. Sixteen months after the concerns were raised, on 19–20 September 2024, he led sessions on equity, diversity and inclusion at the National Aspiring Vice Chancellor Development Programme at Bolton.
He was teaching the next generation of vice-chancellors while the questions about his own record remained unanswered by the institution that employed him.
What Liverpool John Moores Actually Said
On 4 August 2026 Liverpool John Moores issued its statement:
“A confidential procedure was conducted… Professor Arday’s PhD still stands. We will not comment further.”
A procedure was conducted. The degree stands.
It does not say he was cleared. It does not say there was no plagiarism. It does not say the allegations were false. It is an administrative outcome, not a finding of fact.
Cambridge told the world the allegations had been investigated. It called the questions “a vile campaign to undermine his credibility.” It refused to investigate itself. Its rule is simple: misconduct is investigated by the institution where the research was done. A PhD is always written before the candidate becomes a professor. Applied consistently, the rule exempts almost everything.
Arday told the New York Times a “detailed investigation” had “cleared me.” That is his word for a confidential finding nobody else has seen.
The Good Law Project letter, signed by 14,799 people by the afternoon of 4 August, said the allegations were “entirely false” and that investigations had “found no evidence whatsoever of wrongdoing.” Fourteen thousand people put their names to a claim about an investigation none of them had read.
The Times reported that the LJMU panel acknowledged the plagiarism and attributed it in part to a “depleted supervisory team.” The BBC said Arday “did not dispute the allegations of plagiarism.” He offered explanations instead.
The Letter That Changed After People Signed It
On 28 July the Good Law Project letter said both universities had “conducted thorough investigations and found no evidence whatsoever of wrongdoing.”
By 31 July the wording had changed. “Thorough investigations” disappeared. It became simply “investigations have found no evidence.”
Dame Ijeoma Uchegbu’s name was removed. Lord Simon Woolley’s Cambridge title was stripped. The changes were not disclosed. Eleven thousand people had already signed the first version. None of them were told. (Documented via Internet Archive snapshots and reported by Benjamin Ryan)
In Support Of Arday
Professor Sir Simon Baron-Cohen, director of Cambridge’s Autism Research Centre, wrote on 31 July that plagiarism should of course always be investigated — but that he could not stand by and watch an autistic man on the ground while the kicking continued. He called it '“relentless bullying of a vulnerable autistic man” and said it was time to stop.
Fair enough. He is entitled to that view.
But Arday has not made it easy for anyone to ask ordinary questions. He has instructed lawyers. He has reported a journalist and an academic to the police for harassment. He has framed the inquiries themselves as racially motivated. He has said he thought people would just believe him. He has said nobody lives their life with a receipt for every claim.
You cannot demand that scrutiny stop while simultaneously treating every attempt at scrutiny as an attack that requires lawyers and the police.
The Titles the Universities Say Never Existed
His Cambridge pages listed him as Visiting Professor at Glasgow and at Ohio State.
Glasgow said he was never a visiting professor there. Not previously. Not currently. Never. (University of Glasgow statement to The Herald / The Times)
Ohio State said it has no record of an employee by that name. Visiting professors appear in their records. The DEI office he claimed to be attached to closed in February 2025. The biography kept listing it after the office no longer existed. Ohio State noted, fairly, that a non-employment visit would not show in their records. The claim was of a professorship. (Ohio State University statement, reported by Guido Fawkes and others)
Durham said he has no formal position now — only an unpaid association.
Cambridge quietly edited its own page. “Professorial Fellow” became “Fellow.” An MA from Liverpool John Moores disappeared. LJMU confirmed the PhD. It did not answer about the MA. Make of that what you will.
What Cambridge Did the Last Time
Cambridge’s own policy treats plagiarism as serious or gross misconduct that will “normally merit dismissal.”
In 2018 Dr William O’Reilly published a paper containing large sections copied almost verbatim from one of his own undergraduate students. A tribunal ruled it was “the product of negligent acts but was not deliberate.” He remained in post.
Cambridge has a track record. It is not one of dismissal.
WaterAid - The Charity That Does Not Send Volunteers Abroad
Multiple biographies (Simon & Schuster Speakers Bureau, Greenbelt festival, Anglia Ruskin honorary citation, and others) stated, almost word-for-word:
“He has also undertaken and completed relief work in South America and West Africa with WaterAid installing water points, which provide drinkable and clean water.”
This language was repeated across speaker bios and university pages until mid-2025 / early 2026.
What WaterAid said
When The Telegraph contacted the charity in early August 2026, WaterAid pointed to its own published policy, which has a section titled “Why we don’t send volunteers abroad.”
Key points from that policy:
WaterAid does not send volunteers overseas.
It works through local partners and communities.
It does not encourage or facilitate self-funded visits by outsiders.
WaterAid’s response effectively rules out the claim as written.
The Biographies and the Memoir That Softened Themselves
In 2025 the institutions that had repeated the £5.5 million and the extreme running feats began changing their websites. No public note. No explanation.
Simon & Schuster’s Speakers Bureau page once listed £5.5 million for 80 charities, thirty marathons, three hundred miles, six hundred miles. By July 2025 it had become “part of several fundraising teams.” The numbers were gone. A year before the story broke.
Anglia Ruskin altered the text of a speech that had already been delivered. Six hundred miles in six days became twelve. Solo fundraising became collective. Southampton Solent and St Mary’s did the same. None of them admitted the text had been revised.
The memoir follows the same pattern. Between the January proof and the June final edition the specific fundraising figures disappeared. “I’m going to raise a lot of money” became “I’m going to work with a lot of people to raise money.” The extreme running claims do not appear in either version.
The Numbers That Actually Exist
The 2010 JustGiving page records £6,285. The 2011 page records £380 from 21 people. Shooting Star Children’s Hospice confirmed £10,800 over the years. Shelter would not disclose. (documented by Benjamin Ryan)
A CV he submitted for a university job in the mid-2010s claimed just over £1.5 million — including cycling London to Paris, the marathon challenge, the 300 miles, and running Edinburgh to London in six days. A claim on a job application is not a speech. It is a representation made to an employer.
No contemporaneous records support £5 million or £5.5 million. The lifetime target on his own early pages was £250,000 by age 50.
The Advertising Standards Authority
On 22 August and 31 August 2025 formal complaints were made to the Advertising Standards Authority about claims in his biographies. On 11 September 2025 the regulator told the agency Amfo to remove or amend claims that lacked adequate substantiation.
A British regulator acted on this a year before the story broke publicly.
What Else Was In the Thesis
A full Turnitin report on the 2015 thesis identified substantial further uncited material beyond Paula Zwozdiak-Myers: a PhD by Christina P. Ligadu, academic handbooks, other sources. Large blocks appear with minimal alteration and without quotation marks. (Turnitin report published by Bathetic Fallacy on Substack)
The journal corrections deserve a closer look. In the corrected 2018 Social Sciences paper, claims about NVivo coding and an independent second coder were removed. A substantial proportion of the quotes originally attributed to his interview subjects were trimmed or cut. None of that was disclosed in the correction notice. A reader would think only citations had been added.
The Birkbeck Masters That Isn’t Listed
In an October 2022 panel discussion Arday said he had obtained a Masters degree in “psychodynamic practice” from Birkbeck, University of London, and had become a “qualified counsellor.”
That claim does not appear on his Cambridge Faculty of Education page.
It does not appear on his Wikipedia entry.
It does not appear on any of his standard institutional biographies.
Birkbeck does not offer a master’s degree called “psychodynamic practice.” What it does offer is an MSc in Psychodynamic Counselling and Psychotherapy — a three-year part-time course that requires prior relevant experience and cannot be taken full-time.
No entry for Jason Arday appears on the public registers of either the British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy (BACP) or the UK Council for Psychotherapy (UKCP).
He claimed the degree and the status of qualified counsellor.
The specific degree title he used does not currently exist at Birkbeck.
The qualification is absent from his official academic listings.
No independent confirmation of either the degree or the professional registration has been produced.
The Threats and the Brain Tumours
Beyond the pig’s head and the masked man, a 2025 speech listed bullets in the post, rape threats against his daughter, “We’re going to make you top yourself,” someone travelling hours to kill him, failure-risk assessments, and Cambridge telling him to stay quiet. In a letter to Jacqui Smith he added physical assault, being spat on, bananas and bullets on campus, corrosive substances and mutilated animals sent to the family home. Only the pig’s head and the masked-man claims have been examined. The rest remain uncorroborated. When The Guardian asked about the absence of police records he said: “To be honest with you, I thought you’d just believe me. Why would I lie?”
He has said he had a brain tumour removed a fortnight before his PhD viva. The surgery, he said, wiped his memory of the thesis, so he had to re-learn the entire thing and still passed. He has also said that after the PhD he was diagnosed with two further brain tumours, which thankfully turned out to be benign. One memory-wiping operation before the viva. Two more tumours after it. No hospital named. No surgeon named.
The Smaller Claims
In a 2023 podcast he said he had been awarded an MBE in 2017 and turned it down. The 2017 London Gazette contains no such award. Declined honours are never gazetted, so the absence cannot disprove an offer. What it sits against is the word he used: “awarded.” An award is a completed act. A completed award would appear.
Cambridge announced he would donate a £20,000 book advance to charity. Princeton University Press later declined to name the recipients. He has claimed to be deaf in one ear and an Olympic Torch Bearer for London 2012. No strong independent confirmation has been located.
He has said he came out of a professional football club’s academy system and then played semi-professionally. In the BBC Lent Talks he described himself as a youth player at a professional club. No club name has ever been given. The Telegraph asked him which academy and which semi-professional side. No public answer has appeared. His memoir contains no mention of either.
The only named club association that surfaces in public sources is a 2018 photograph of him accepting an award on behalf of Battersea Park Rangers (Southern Sunday Football League). That is amateur Sunday league football.
He has also said he was on the verge of turning professional at snooker, and some profiles claimed he joined a professional tour. The University of Bath corrected its own blog to state that he said he did not pursue snooker professionally. CueTracker, the main snooker results database, records one match for an amateur called Jason Arday: a first-round defeat 4–0 in the 2002 Amateur Snooker Championships. That appears to be the only recorded competitive match. No record of him on any professional tour has been found.
One claim that circulated should not have. It was widely reported that he had joined a professional snooker tour. The University of Bath has since corrected its own blog: he said semi-professional football and that he did not pursue snooker professionally.
Teaching and Student Complaints
Multiple students and former colleagues have publicly described Arday’s teaching as poor and disorganised. The most detailed account appeared on Reddit (r/AskAcademiaUK, 27 July 2026). A former student at the University of Roehampton wrote that Arday “arrived at 4 hour lectures over an hour late and usually left after an hour,” sat on a desk talking generally about racism and celebrities, and that “we learned absolutely nothing.” The student said Arday relied on claims of autism and minority status to attack anyone who questioned his work. After several complaints a lead academic sat in on one of the lectures; the faculty were said to be reluctant to act for fear of being called racist. Arday left of his own accord. A follow-up comment in the same thread claimed the course head had said they would not employ him again.
A widely circulated X post by @DionLeFou (3 August 2026) made the same points: numerous complaints over lectures, a senior academic sitting in, and Arday defending himself with autism and racism claims before leaving.
None of these claims have been independently verified. No formal student complaints, internal reports, or official records have been produced or published. The accounts remain unverified student and staff testimony shared on social media. (Reddit, r/AskAcademiaUK, 27 July 2026; similar account posted on X by @DionLeFou, 3 August 2026)
BBC Radio 4 Today debate – “Do we need a monarchy?” (April 2023)
Arday argues for abolishing the monarchy and redistributing its funding. In the circulating clip he says there are people “suffering at unprecedented levels,” that there is an “opportunity” if the monarchy were abolished, and that the resources should be given “to the majority of society who don’t have.”
Multiple posts (including the original BBC post and widely quoted versions) attribute to him the additional claim that 70% of the UK population live below the “bread line” and that abolishing the monarchy would allow that money to be redistributed to them.
The Appointment
The Board of Electors was chaired by Baroness Sally Morgan. Arday published his first paper in 2018. Senior lecturer the same year. Associate professor at Durham. Full professor at Glasgow in 2021. Cambridge chair in 2023. Five years from first publication to an Oxbridge professorship. Everything the board needed was already public. The publication list. The £5.5 million claim. The running claims. Nobody had to be a detective. Somebody had to be curious.
The Pattern
Each claim follows the same sequence. It appears. Institutions repeat it. When it is checked it fails or evaporates. The biography is quietly edited. Anyone who notices is told the questions themselves are the problem.
People did check. Harris checked and was reported to the police. Hammersley checked and was told it was not Cambridge’s business. The ASA checked and told a company to amend its claims. Grove checked for months, was threatened by a law firm, had his story killed, and was investigated by the Metropolitan Police for four months without being interviewed.
When the confidential procedure at Liverpool John Moores finished, its result — a degree that still stands — was carried into the world as an exoneration. By a university. By a campaigning organisation. By the man himself. To 14,799 people who had no way of knowing what the finding actually said.
That is the story. Not simply a man who told tall stories. A machine that turns “we are not going to tell you what we found” into “he has been cleared,” and treats everyone who asks to see the working as a bigot.
Jason Arday says he is not a liar. He says his errors stem from autism and inadequate supervision. He says he is the victim of a racially motivated campaign. He is entitled to say so. He is also entitled to the one thing nobody has given him: a proper, independent, published investigation by people with no stake in the answer, whose findings anyone can read.
Robert Dingwall has called for exactly that. John Preston says there is a case to answer and the evidence triangulates. Colin Mills at Oxford has said he does not want his discipline smeared by association with academic fraud and low standards. The Office for Students says it cannot comment on individual cases.
These are not campaigners. They are senior academics in the field asking for the one thing that would settle it.
The institutions that elevated the legend have spent the last year quietly walking pieces of it back while insisting that the scrutiny, not the claims, is the real issue. The record is now long enough that the pattern itself is the evidence.
The Claims, Laid Out Together
Here, in one place, is the full set of claims Jason Arday has made about his life:
Diagnosed with autism and global developmental delay at the age of three.
Non-verbal until the age of eleven.
Unable to read or write until the age of eighteen.
Four to five hours of speech therapy every day from the age of three.
A mother with five degrees.
A benign brain tumour removed a fortnight before his PhD viva, which wiped his memory of the entire thesis; he re-learned it and still passed.
Two further brain tumours diagnosed after the PhD, later found to be benign.
Deaf in one ear.
Ran 30 marathons in 35 days, the last nine after sustaining a hairline fracture that made his leg swell to twice its normal size.
Covered 300 miles in three days.
Covered 600 miles in six days (later quietly amended in some citations to twelve days).
Raised £5.5 million for more than 80 charities.
Installed water points in South America and West Africa with WaterAid.
Received a severed pig’s head at his parents’ home.
Faced a knife-wielding masked man.
Received bullets in the post, rape threats against his daughter, threats to make him “top himself,” and other forms of intimidation including corrosive substances and mutilated animals.
Came through a professional football club’s academy system and later played semi-professionally.
Was on the verge of turning professional at snooker.
Awarded an MBE in 2017 and turned it down.
Olympic Torch Bearer for London 2012.
Appeared in the ITV documentary series Seven Up!.
Obtained a Masters degree in “psychodynamic practice” from Birkbeck and became a qualified counsellor.
Held visiting professorships at the University of Glasgow and Ohio State University.
This is the origin story as it has been told. Almost none of it has been independently verified. Several of the most dramatic claims have been directly contradicted by the organisations or records that should corroborate them.
That is the real failure.
In the rush to be diverse, to be inclusive, to champion a Black, autistic, working-class success story who ticked every box, almost no one stopped to ask the simplest question of all: when you look at these claims as a totality, how plausible are they?
Each claim on its own might have been given the benefit of the doubt. Taken together they form a pattern that should have been obvious long before Carter-Ruck letters and police complaints were required to shut the questions down.
The institutions that elevated the legend spent years repeating it. When the contradictions began to surface they did not investigate. They defended. They edited the websites quietly. They called the scrutiny a vile campaign. They treated the act of checking as the real offence.
Jason Arday did not need to invent a modest success story. He invented a legend. And for years almost no one dared to ask whether any of it was real — because he is Black, and in the current climate that was supposed to be enough.
It was not enough. And it never should have been.
This article is written in good faith, having assessed the evidence available to the best of my knowledge. This is my personal assessment of it.
Professor Arday denies the allegations of plagiarism and has said he is the victim of a racially motivated campaign. Liverpool John Moores University has stated that his PhD still stands.
I write about policing, justice and the things institutions would rather we did not say – drawing on 21 years of police service. If this reached you, share it. Subscribe for upcoming articles directly to your inbox.
This piece is free to read, but let me be honest with you, as I always try to be. I have severe M.E. – a chronic illness that limits my energy, my concentration and what I can do in a day. The job I loved broke my health. Writing something like this costs me: it means crashes, days lost, exhaustion that’s hard to describe. I take days, sometimes weeks, on each article. It would be the sensible thing not to do it at all. I do it anyway, in the small way I can, because the truth and justice matters.
If this work means something to you, a paid subscription at £5 a month helps me keep writing. So does a one-off through Buy Me A Coffee. Neither is expected. Both are genuinely appreciated – and if you can’t, sharing this costs nothing and matters just as much. Thank you for reading my work.





A post-modern Frankenstein.
A composite man, made by others for their fantasist desires.
I don't know whether to laugh or cry. The whole thing is like some comedy sketch. Arday himself clearly has some issues and a somewhat tenuous relationship to truth.
As an ex-academic (theoretical physics) I don't always take too much of an issue with plagiarism when it's a matter of mere phrasing. It's still wrong, but copying someone else's explanation of a known concept or known research or, ahem, borrowing their phrasing without attribution is relatively minor. Still wrong though.
Where it's a (very) serious issue is when you take someone's original research or insight or results and pass them off as your own. In my view that should warrant instant dismissal.
The deeper issue for me is not so much integrity (although that's obviously very important) but one of *quality*.
I have no intention of reading any of Arday's work - life is far too short - and will trust Cofnas' assessment of it. The thing here is that the work itself does not even come remotely close to anything I would consider to be at "professorial" level. I'd be even harsher to be honest. I don't even see why it should have been published in academic journals at all, falling way below the standards of academic rigour and methodology I would expect.
So the big question - to which we all know the answer - is how on earth did he get away with it?