Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Georg Elsner's avatar

A post-modern Frankenstein.

A composite man, made by others for their fantasist desires.

Rudolph Rigger's avatar

I don't know whether to laugh or cry. The whole thing is like some comedy sketch. Arday himself clearly has some issues and a somewhat tenuous relationship to truth.

As an ex-academic (theoretical physics) I don't always take too much of an issue with plagiarism when it's a matter of mere phrasing. It's still wrong, but copying someone else's explanation of a known concept or known research or, ahem, borrowing their phrasing without attribution is relatively minor. Still wrong though.

Where it's a (very) serious issue is when you take someone's original research or insight or results and pass them off as your own. In my view that should warrant instant dismissal.

The deeper issue for me is not so much integrity (although that's obviously very important) but one of *quality*.

I have no intention of reading any of Arday's work - life is far too short - and will trust Cofnas' assessment of it. The thing here is that the work itself does not even come remotely close to anything I would consider to be at "professorial" level. I'd be even harsher to be honest. I don't even see why it should have been published in academic journals at all, falling way below the standards of academic rigour and methodology I would expect.

So the big question - to which we all know the answer - is how on earth did he get away with it?

71 more comments...

Ready for more?